DSE Physics Diagnostic Guide
DSE Physics Diagnostic Guide
Overview
This diagnostic system covers all 10 core topics of the HKDSE Physics examination. Each topic file contains 3 unit tests (single-topic, testing deep understanding) and 3 integration tests (multi-topic, testing synthesis and application). All questions target the upper difficulty band of the DSE specification.
Topic Coverage Map
| # | File | Topic | Key Concepts Tested |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | diag-mechanics.md | Mechanics | SUVAT selection, projectile independence, sign conventions, multi-stage motion |
| 2 | diag-forces-motion.md | Forces and Motion | N3L pairs, inclined planes, connected objects, friction direction |
| 3 | diag-energy-work.md | Energy and Work | Work at angles, power-velocity, efficiency chains, non-conservative forces |
| 4 | diag-waves-sound.md | Waves and Sound | Standing waves, intensity/dB, beats, Doppler effect, pipe harmonics |
| 5 | diag-optics.md | Optics | Thin lens sign convention, TIR, compound systems, apparent depth |
| 6 | diag-waves-optics.md | Waves and Optics | Diffraction, interference, polarization, EM spectrum, thin films |
| 7 | diag-electrical-circuits.md | Electrical Circuits | Kirchhoff”s laws, internal resistance, potentiometer, RC circuits |
| 8 | diag-electricity-magnetism.md | Electricity and Magnetism | Faraday/Lenz laws, transformers, back EMF, electromagnetic braking |
| 9 | diag-heat-gases.md | Heat and Gases | Latent heat, gas law units, kinetic theory, adiabatic processes |
| 10 | diag-nuclear-physics.md | Nuclear Physics | Half-life, binding energy, decay chains, mass-energy equivalence |
Prerequisite Chains
Mechanics (1) | vForces and Motion (2) ---> Energy and Work (3) | | v vWaves and Sound (4) ---> Waves and Optics (6) | | v vOptics (5) Electrical Circuits (7) | v Electricity and Magnetism (8)
Heat and Gases (9) -----> Nuclear Physics (10)Recommended diagnostic order:
- Foundation tier: Mechanics, Forces and Motion, Energy and Work
- Waves tier: Waves and Sound, Waves and Optics, Optics
- Electromagnetic tier: Electrical Circuits, Electricity and Magnetism
- Thermal/Nuclear tier: Heat and Gases, Nuclear Physics
Grading Rubric
Scoring per Question
Each question is scored on a 4-level scale:
| Level | Descriptor | Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| 4 - Mastery | Complete and correct | Correct final answer, valid method, appropriate units, no significant errors |
| 3 - Proficient | Minor errors only | Correct approach but arithmetic or algebraic slip; or correct answer with incomplete working |
| 2 - Developing | Partial understanding | Correct setup of some equations but unable to complete; or conceptual error in one step |
| 1 - Beginning | Significant gaps | Wrong approach or fundamental misconception; only isolated correct elements |
| 0 - No attempt | Blank or irrelevant | No meaningful physics content |
Diagnostic Interpretation
Per-topic score (out of 24: 6 questions x 4 marks each):
| Score | Band | Interpretation | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22-24 | A | Excellent mastery | Move to integration tests of other topics; consider extension work |
| 18-21 | B | Good understanding | Review missed questions; focus on specific weak spots |
| 12-17 | C | Adequate foundation | Revisit topic notes; practise with standard textbook exercises first |
| 6-11 | D | Significant gaps | Study the topic from fundamentals; use worked examples as templates |
| 0-5 | U | Major intervention needed | Seek teacher support; start with basic concepts before attempting diagnostics |
Overall Diagnostic Profile
Sum all 10 topic scores (max 240):
| Total | Band | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| 216-240 | 5** | Exam-ready for physics; focus on exam technique and time management |
| 180-215 | 5 | Strong candidate; target specific weaker topics for improvement |
| 144-179 | 4 | Solid foundation; systematic topic-by-topic review recommended |
| 108-143 | 3 | Moderate gaps; prioritise foundation-tier topics first |
| 72-107 | 2 | Significant review needed; consider structured study plan |
| 0-71 | 1 | Intensive intervention; work through prerequisite chain from the start |
Common Pitfalls by Topic
Mechanics
- Using distance instead of displacement in SUVAT equations
- Forgetting that projectile horizontal velocity is constant
- Wrong sign for when taking upward as positive
- Choosing the wrong SUVAT equation for the given unknown
Forces and Motion
- Drawing action-reaction pairs on the same body
- Assuming normal force always equals weight
- Getting friction direction wrong (it opposes relative motion, not the applied force)
- Forgetting to include all forces in free-body diagrams
Energy and Work
- Using instead of for angled forces
- Assuming conservation of energy when non-conservative forces are present
- Confusing efficiency = output/input with input/output
- Forgetting that power only when and are in the same direction
Waves and Sound
- Confusing wave speed with particle velocity
- Misidentifying longitudinal vs transverse waves
- Forgetting that standing waves require specific boundary conditions
- Using amplitude instead of frequency in the wave equation
Optics
- Wrong sign convention in thin lens equation
- Confusing real and virtual images
- Forgetting that total internal reflection requires the ray to go from denser to less dense medium
- Incorrect magnification sign interpretation
Waves and Optics
- Forgetting that diffraction requires gap size comparable to wavelength
- Wrong path difference conditions for constructive/destructive interference
- Assuming polarisation applies to all waves (only transverse)
- Confusing the order of the electromagnetic spectrum
Electrical Circuits
- Confusing current direction with electron flow direction
- Mixing up EMF and terminal PD
- Wrong formula for parallel resistance (Not )
- Ignoring internal resistance in calculations
Electricity and Magnetism
- Using the wrong hand rule (Fleming’s left vs right)
- Confusing Faraday’s law (magnitude) with Lenz’s law (direction)
- Forgetting that back EMF reduces motor current
- Wrong transformer equation application
Heat and Gases
- Using Celsius instead of Kelvin in gas law calculations
- Confusing specific heat capacity with latent heat
- Forgetting that differs for monatomic and diatomic gases
- Incorrect adiabatic vs isothermal process identification
Nuclear Physics
- Using instead of in
- Confusing half-life with mean life
- Misinterpreting the binding energy per nucleon curve
- Forgetting that requires mass to actually be converted (not just present)
Study Strategy
For students scoring Band A or B on a topic:
- Attempt the integration tests in other topics that reference this topic
- Try to create your own multi-topic problems
- Time yourself under exam conditions (approximately 12 minutes per question for DSE)
For students scoring Band C or D on a topic:
- Return to the main topic notes and review systematically
- Work through textbook examples before retrying diagnostic questions
- Focus on understanding WHY each step works, not just memorising procedures
For students scoring Band U on a topic:
- Start with the prerequisite topics in the chain above
- Build up from basic definitions and concepts
- Use the unit tests as learning exercises (read the solution, then attempt similar problems)
Summary
The key principles covered in this topic are linked in the sub-pages above. Focus on understanding the definitions, applying the formulas or frameworks, and evaluating strengths and limitations of each approach.
Worked Examples
Worked examples demonstrating the application of key concepts are covered in the detailed sub-pages linked above.